At some point during an intro to philosophy class in college, I was first exposed to the classic "Brain in a vat" thought experiment: how do I know I'm not just a brain in a vat of goo with a bunch of wires and probes poking out, being measured and controlled by some mad scientist? That was a few years before The Matrix came out, which asked essentially the same question.
So -- are you a brain in a vat? And how could you know?
This is just the tip of the iceberg; once we start down this path, we come face-to-face with more difficult questions. "What creates consciousness?" "Can consciousness be simulated?" "If I copy my brain, will it create another me, and what would that feel like?" And once we've fallen down the rabbit hole, we see that there are a thousand other seemingly unanswerable questions... questions about free will, the arrow of time, the nature of reality, and so forth.
I think physics can help answer these questions, and in fact I think I have answered a couple of them to some degree. For example, I don't know (yet) whether I'm in a simulation, but I think I do know whether or not I am a simulation. Here is my first YouTube talk in which I explain why consciousness cannot be algorithmic, conscious states cannot be copied or repeated, and computers will never be conscious:
If you prefer a written explanation, here is a preprint of my article, "Refuting Strong AI: Why Consciousness Cannot Be Algorithmic."
I am also working on another proof of the same conclusions from a different angle. Here is a preprint of my article, "Killing Science Fiction: Why Conscious States Cannot Be Copied or Repeated." I'll post a link to a YouTube talk on this paper as soon as it's available.
So -- are you a brain in a vat? And how could you know?
This is just the tip of the iceberg; once we start down this path, we come face-to-face with more difficult questions. "What creates consciousness?" "Can consciousness be simulated?" "If I copy my brain, will it create another me, and what would that feel like?" And once we've fallen down the rabbit hole, we see that there are a thousand other seemingly unanswerable questions... questions about free will, the arrow of time, the nature of reality, and so forth.
I think physics can help answer these questions, and in fact I think I have answered a couple of them to some degree. For example, I don't know (yet) whether I'm in a simulation, but I think I do know whether or not I am a simulation. Here is my first YouTube talk in which I explain why consciousness cannot be algorithmic, conscious states cannot be copied or repeated, and computers will never be conscious:
If you prefer a written explanation, here is a preprint of my article, "Refuting Strong AI: Why Consciousness Cannot Be Algorithmic."
I am also working on another proof of the same conclusions from a different angle. Here is a preprint of my article, "Killing Science Fiction: Why Conscious States Cannot Be Copied or Repeated." I'll post a link to a YouTube talk on this paper as soon as it's available.
No comments:
Post a Comment
All comments are moderated. After submitting your comment, please give me 24 hours to approve. Thanks!